The threshold: for $10,000 of card debt and $500 a month to split between debt and retirement, taking a 50% employer match first leaves you better off after 10 years whenever the card’s rate is below 26.8%. With a 100% match the threshold rises to 34.2%; with a 25% match it falls to 19.6%. The deciding factor is whether the money left after contributing still pays the debt down quickly.
What the comparison measures
Two plans, same monthly budget. Match first: contribute enough to get the full match ($150 a month here) and put the rest toward the debt; once the debt is gone, everything goes to the 401(k). Debt first: put the whole budget toward the debt, then switch it all to the 401(k). We compare net worth after 10 years: the 401(k) balance minus any remaining debt.
A match is an instant return: a 50% match turns $100 into $150 the day it’s contributed. Paying debt returns the card’s rate, compounding until the balance would otherwise have been paid. The match wins unless diverting money to the 401(k) slows the payoff so much that the extra interest outweighs the match.
$10,000 at $500 a month, 50% match
| Card APR | Match first vs. debt first, after 10 years |
|---|---|
| 12% | +$2,324 for match first |
| 18% | +$1,780 for match first |
| 22% | +$1,172 for match first |
| 24% | +$729 for match first |
| 29% | −$788 for debt first |
Break-even card rate by debt, budget and match
Below these rates, taking the match first comes out ahead; above them, paying the debt first does.
| Debt | Monthly budget | 25% match | 50% match | 100% match |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5,000 | $400 | 25.9% | 37.2% | 47.7% |
| $5,000 | $500 | 34.6% | 49.9% | above 60% |
| $5,000 | $750 | 55.2% | above 60% | above 60% |
| $5,000 | $1,000 | above 60% | above 60% | above 60% |
| $10,000 | $400 | 15.5% | 20.5% | 25.5% |
| $10,000 | $500 | 19.6% | 26.8% | 34.2% |
| $10,000 | $750 | 29.9% | 42.7% | 55.7% |
| $10,000 | $1,000 | 40.1% | 59.0% | above 60% |
| $20,000 | $750 | 17.4% | 23.4% | 29.2% |
| $20,000 | $1,000 | 22.6% | 31.2% | 40.0% |
The pattern: break-even rates fall sharply as the budget gets tight relative to the debt. When the money left after contributing barely covers the interest, the debt lingers and the match can’t keep up. Combinations where that remainder wouldn’t cover a 22% card’s interest at all are left out.
Assumptions
- 401(k) investments grow 6% a year; the card rate is fixed; there are no new charges.
- Contributions are counted in after-tax terms, assuming the same tax rate when money goes in and comes out, so taxes don’t favor either plan.
- The match is fully vested. If you might leave before vesting, the effective match is lower, which pushes the break-even rate down.
- Card interest follows our standard monthly method.