Home / Guides

Balance transfer vs. personal loan vs. HELOC vs. 401(k) loan

Total cost by balance and card rate, plus the risks each one carries.

Reviewed November 21, 2026

The threshold: over 36 months, a balance transfer costs less than an 11% personal loan when the card’s rate after the promotion is below 21.3%, and more when it’s above. Repaying $10,000 from a 22% card, the card alone costs about $3,749 in interest, a transfer about $1,850 and the loan about $1,786, so the personal loan is cheaper. Clearing the balance within the 15-month promotion changes the picture: that takes $687 a month, and the transfer then costs only its $300 fee. A HELOC or a 401(k) loan costs less on paper, but moves the risk onto your home or your retirement savings.

Total cost of repaying over 36 months

Interest and fees for each option, with equal monthly payments over 36 months:

BalanceCard APRStay on cardBalance transferPersonal loanHELOC401(k) loan*Cheaper unsecured option
$5,00018%$1,507$756$893$682$482Balance transfer
$5,00022%$1,874$925$893$682$482Personal loan
$5,00029%$2,543$1,256$893$682$482Personal loan
$10,00018%$3,015$1,512$1,786$1,364$963Balance transfer
$10,00022%$3,749$1,850$1,786$1,364$963Personal loan
$10,00029%$5,086$2,512$1,786$1,364$963Personal loan
$20,00018%$6,030$3,025$3,572$2,729$1,926Balance transfer
$20,00022%$7,497$3,700$3,572$2,729$1,926Personal loan
$20,00029%$10,172$5,023$3,572$2,729$1,926Personal loan
$30,00018%$9,045$4,537$5,358$4,093$2,889Balance transfer
$30,00022%$11,246$5,551$5,358$4,093$2,889Personal loan
$30,00029%$15,258$7,535$5,358$4,093$2,889Personal loan

*For the 401(k) loan, the figure is investment growth given up while the money is out of the market, at 6% a year. The interest you pay on a 401(k) loan goes back into your own account, so it isn’t counted as a cost.

How each option works, and its main risk

  • Balance transfer: 3% fee and 15 months at 0%, then the card’s regular rate on whatever remains. Approval and the credit limit depend on your credit, and a limit below your balance means only part can move.
  • Personal loan at 11%: a fixed payment and end date. Rates vary widely with credit, and some lenders deduct an origination fee, which isn’t included above.
  • HELOC at 8.5%: usually a lower, variable rate, but the debt is secured by your home, so falling behind can put the home at risk. Closing costs, which vary, aren’t included.
  • 401(k) loan: you borrow from your own retirement account and repay yourself with interest[16]. If you leave your job, the remaining balance may come due quickly; an unpaid loan can be treated as a distribution, subject to income tax and, before age 59½, generally a 10% additional tax[17].

Assumptions

  • Rates: personal loan 11%, HELOC 8.5% (fixed for this comparison, though HELOCs are usually variable), 401(k) loan 8.5% paid to yourself, investment growth 6%.
  • Balance transfer: 3% fee added to the balance, 15 months at 0%, then the card APR shown, paid in equal installments.
  • All options are repaid in equal monthly payments over 36 months using our standard monthly method. Actual offers depend on your credit and lender.